Kurzbesprechung der Variationen über “Schöne Minka”
- 1. Variations on a favourite Russian Air for the Piano-Forte, by C. M. de Weber. (Cocks and Co., Princes St., Hanover Square.)
- […]
The first of these is an air now well known amongst us: — M. Weber’s variations to it shew his science and invention, and his introduction to them is in the fine romantic style of his overtures; but like nearly all the music written by him for the piano-forte, the performer is not considered for one moment; the passages are, with scarcely an exception, so ill-adapted to the hand, the skips are so unnatural, the notes are so crowded, and the necessary contrast of light and shade, — of unencumbered melody and full harmony — is so entirely neglected, that we cannot recommend our readers to torment themselves with this composition; except indeed such as are of the ultra party; those we must resign to their taste. […]
Editorial
Summary
Webers Variationen für das Piano-Forte über das Thema der schönen Minka seien schlecht adaptiert, die Noten zu dicht und die Sprünge zu unnatürlich. Es wird daher von den Variationen abgeraten.
Creation
–
Responsibilities
- Übertragung
- Fabian Schmidt
Tradition
-
Text Source: The Harmonicon, vol. 4/1, Nr. 47 (November 1826), pp. 224
